“The bass solo in My Generation is one of the classic bass things of all time. And John Entwistle said it was the bane of his life”: Rick Wakeman explains the problem with recording a classic solo, and how he experienced it with Yes’s Close To The Edge (2024)

Rick Wakeman On Prog Rock, Keyboards and His Legendary Career With Yes - YouTube“The bass solo in My Generation is one of the classic bass things of all time. And John Entwistle said it was the bane of his life”: Rick Wakeman explains the problem with recording a classic solo, and how he experienced it with Yes’s Close To The Edge (1)

Watch On

John Entwistle’s bass solo on The Who’s My Generation remains one of the greatest of all time - not to mention one of the first in rock history - but his friend Rick Wakeman has revealed that it became a bit of an albatross for him.

Discussing his own organ solo on Yes’s Close To The Edge with YouTuber Rick Beato, Wakeman cites what he calls the ‘John Entwistle My Generation syndrome’, and goes on to explain what that means.

“The bass solo in My Generation is one of the classic bass things of all time,” says Wakeman. “And John said it was the bane of his life. He said, ‘because it was a solo.’

“‘We're in the studio,’ he said, ‘I did it and that was it.’ It became a huge hit and he said ‘then we go out and we're playing, and it comes to my bit, so I do a solo,’ and people would come and go, ‘played that wrong.’ And he said, ‘No, I didn't, it's a solo,’ and [they’d say] ‘played it wrong. You didn't play it right.’ And he said it happened so many times.

“Even reviewers said, ‘such a shame that John played the bass bit wrong.’ So he said, ‘One day I went, fuck it. I sat in the hotel with my bass and a little Pignose amp, and I learned what I’d played. That was the only way.’

“It’s interesting, sometimes, when a solo actually becomes a part. It becomes a part. It becomes a part of the music. It's no longer a solo.”

My Generation (Stereo Version) - YouTube“The bass solo in My Generation is one of the classic bass things of all time. And John Entwistle said it was the bane of his life”: Rick Wakeman explains the problem with recording a classic solo, and how he experienced it with Yes’s Close To The Edge (2)

Watch On

Wakeman seems to be implying that he considers a solo to be something that’s improvised in the moment. However, when it ends up on an album and people expect you to recreate it, note for note, it becomes something else.

“I had that a little bit with the Close To The Edge thing, because I had to learn it,” he says. “It was all right. You know, these things happen, but the truth of the matter is, there is no such thing as a solo on record. It doesn't exist. It's a feeling of that time. It becomes fixed in time.”

How to play synth solos like Rick Wakeman

Close to the Edge Organ Solo - Transcription & Performance - YouTube“The bass solo in My Generation is one of the classic bass things of all time. And John Entwistle said it was the bane of his life”: Rick Wakeman explains the problem with recording a classic solo, and how he experienced it with Yes’s Close To The Edge (3)

Watch On

Elsewhere in the interview, Wakeman also discusses his friend Elton John, and suggests that his skills in certain musical areas have partially obscured his talent in another.

“One of the things that people forget about Elton John is, because he's such an amazing songwriter and the singer - what a good player,” he says. “He's a great player. He's a really good player, but it sort of gets lost a bit because of his singing and the songwriting.”

“The bass solo in My Generation is one of the classic bass things of all time. And John Entwistle said it was the bane of his life”: Rick Wakeman explains the problem with recording a classic solo, and how he experienced it with Yes’s Close To The Edge (4)

More about keyboards pianos

“Launchkeys are a reminder that sometimes a keyboard is still what you need, even with Ableton Live”: Novation Launchkey MK4 25 and 37 reviewWith a mind-blowing £800 off the Korg Poetry, is this the best piano deal we are likely to see this Black Friday?

Latest

"Tackling ableism, inaccessibility and discrimination should be a priority for the entire music industry”: The startling systemic issues facing disabled musicians highlighted in new report

Categories

“The bass solo in My Generation is one of the classic bass things of all time. And John Entwistle said it was the bane of his life”: Rick Wakeman explains the problem with recording a classic solo, and how he experienced it with Yes’s Close To The Edge (8)

Ben Rogerson

Deputy Editor

I’m the Deputy Editor of MusicRadar, having worked on the site since its launch in 2007. I previously spent eight years working on our sister magazine, Computer Music. I’ve been playing the piano, gigging in bands and failing to finish tracks at home for more than 30 years, 24 of which I’ve also spent writing about music and the ever-changing technology used to make it.

More about keyboards pianos

“Launchkeys are a reminder that sometimes a keyboard is still what you need, even with Ableton Live”: Novation Launchkey MK4 25 and 37 reviewWith a mind-blowing £800 off the Korg Poetry, is this the best piano deal we are likely to see this Black Friday?

Latest

"Tackling ableism, inaccessibility and discrimination should be a priority for the entire music industry”: The startling systemic issues facing disabled musicians highlighted in new report
See more latest►

Most Popular
Rod Stewart to “pleasure and titillate” Glastonbury 2025
Score an impressive $240 off the stunning Forest Green Strat and Tele in Fender's first-ever Player II sale this Black Friday
“It has been such a long time coming. I’ve wanted to make a Chapman amp for years”: Rob Chapman is branching out into tube amps and promises buttery cleans and “heavy, chewy, saturated gain”
“An outstanding selection of delay tones in a budget-friendly and space-saving enclosure”: Nobels’ DEL-mini offers three delays and the width of the stereo spread all from a super-compact $99 pedal
"A campaign to manipulate and saturate the streaming services and airwaves": Drake starts legal action against Universal and Spotify over Kendrick diss tracks rumpus
"When the worst instrumentalist in your group is John Lennon, you’ve got a pretty good group”: Was John Lennon a good guitarist? And does it really matter?
Sculpt your sounds on a spectral level with Manatee, a multitimbral, MPE-equipped desktop synth from Fred's Lab
Gibson slaps Trump guitars with a cease and desist order
“This poses a risk of serious electric shock”: Blackstar Amplification issues urgent product safety recall for Debut 100R combos
Fender's massive Black Friday sale is here! Bag up to 50% off 75 guitars - these are the 8 we'd pick up today
Aerosmith out - Muppets in: Disney World rebrand the ‘Rock N’ Roller Coaster’ at their Florida theme park
“The bass solo in My Generation is one of the classic bass things of all time. And John Entwistle said it was the bane of his life”: Rick Wakeman explains the problem with recording a classic solo, and how he experienced it with Yes’s Close To The Edge (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Ray Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 5842

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (69 voted)

Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ray Christiansen

Birthday: 1998-05-04

Address: Apt. 814 34339 Sauer Islands, Hirtheville, GA 02446-8771

Phone: +337636892828

Job: Lead Hospitality Designer

Hobby: Urban exploration, Tai chi, Lockpicking, Fashion, Gunsmithing, Pottery, Geocaching

Introduction: My name is Ray Christiansen, I am a fair, good, cute, gentle, vast, glamorous, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.